Living Plastic Free: Lipstick

Written by EnviroWoman
Live Plastic-Free in 2007
Plant Love by Cargo uses eco-friendly compostable bioplastic

After getting all braniac from her trip to Oz, EnviroWoman decided she needed a GirlyGirl reward.

So she bought lipstick!

One thousand and one. One thousand and two.

Okay, in those two seconds, 90% of TheTestosterones just hit the Browser Back button. Bye, bye boys. But come back soon. Maybe next time EnviroWoman will blog about plastic-free hockey pucks or beer. Ya never know.

The other 10% of TheTestosterones diverted their attention from the computer monitor during those 2 seconds to yell over their shoulder ‘HoneyBun, SweetiePie, ya gotta come read this…EnviroWoman is talking lipstick.’ Oh boys, we so love you for that. Brownie points galore! Plus a little plastic-free peck on the cheek from EnviroWoman.

Now that leaves the rest of us. Girrrllllsss!!!!!

And women….it’s true, today EnviroWoman celebrates…..miracle of miracles….plastic-free lipstick. "

You’ve probably already heard about it, ‘cuz its getting plenty of buzz.

The stuff is Plant Love by Cargo Cosmetics.

EnviroWoman hates to admit it – but I bought it strictly for its packaging!!! Because it’s so revolutionary. Evolutionary, really. The first of its kind in the cosmetics industry. A serious injection of eco-cool.

The lipstick tube is made of PLA…the friendly bioplastic EnviroWoman discovered on her trip to Oz. You know, GoodWitchoftheNorthBioplastic. Made of corn. Completely compostable. Biodegrades within 100 days, into completely benign, non-toxic particles. Greenhouse-gas-neutral. Doesn't even like to call itself 'plastic' bioplastic.

Good, happy-planet stuff.

And they tell me, it’s cruelty-free too. Contains jojoba and shea butter. No petroleum, or mineral oil. No animal byproducts. Never tested on innocent sweet lives.

Good, happy-animal stuff.

And the accompanying box is also completely biodegradable and embedded with wildflower seeds, so you can plant it and watch it grow. (Although a trusted source tells me similar seeded-paper often ‘cooks’ the seeds during the paper-making process. So the seeds never grow.)

There’s 12 girly Plant Love shades. Cargo claims five were ‘designed’ by celebs (like Lindsay Lohan, and Evangline Lily) Yeah, like I really believe that and do I really care. The other 7 shades were inspired by natural beauty (like Canada’s own Nahinni, or the US’s Yellowstone). Well, I kinda believe that, but it’s probably just marketing fluff, and again, do I really care.

As with any lipstick, there are two fundamental tests its gotta pass:

  1. Numero Uno is….staying power. EnviroWoman rates it as about a 5.
  2. Numero Dos is the ‘kissable’ taste-test. TheBeast gives it an 8 (but she’d rate any kiss from MyHuman as an 8 - even if it truthfully tasted DoggyDoDoRaunchy. She loves me. I love her). On the other hand, MyMcDreamy gives it a 4.

EnviroWoman has to admit, my immediate reaction to the first application was 'Ugh, this is a bit DoggyDoDoRaunchy’. TheBeast will probably love it.’ But, it seems to taste better now (maybe I’m just so determined to like this stuff, my objectivity is all puckered up).

Despite this, let’s all blow a kiss to Cargo – for being the first in the industry to use PLA bioplastics. And let’s hope they are not the last. Let’s hope this is the sign of things to come.

Because…..be honest Girrllllss – have you ever, ever, ever tossed an empty lipstick tube in the recycling bin? Probably not. I don’t think I’ve ever even seen any marked with a recycling symbol. My BodyShop lipsticks from 2006 aren’t. So most lipsticks should never grace your recycling bin….and if you’re tossing them there…you’re just fooling yourself. A plastic that isn’t marked with a Plastic Resin Code shouldn’t be recycled.

And hugs to anyone who buys Plant Love. Not just because they’re supporting an eco-friendly product and helping to build demand, but also because they’re forking out a whopping $20 bucks a tube. Although, Cargo buffers this by donating $2 to St. Jude’s Children’s Research Hospital. (EnviroWoman wonders….why wouldn’t an eco-friendly product donate its money to an environmental cause?)

If you’re interested in checking it out, visit BeautyMark, in Yaletown.

So here’s how things add up:

Category: Lipstick

SAINT: Plant Love by Cargo….made of corn-based compostable bioplastic. Bonus points for being cruelty-free.

Price: $20.

Quality: Not as long-lasting as others, but not bad. Okay colors, though some are a bit too sparkly, even for this GirlyGirl.

SINNER: Body Shop (you don’t know how much it pains me to say that), L’Oreal, Revlon, Cover Girl, Lise Watier, Marcelle, Almay...oh hell, all of 'em...

Lessons Learned:

  • Support the trailblazers when they appear to be blazing the right trail. Give them your money. Create the demand. Follow them as they walk you into a better future.
  • Vanity should do no harm. In an ideal world (which hopefully we’ll get to in EnviroWoman's lifetime) something as frivioulous as makeup shouldn’t hurt the planet…or any of its creatures.
  • Beasts love unconditionally, even when your kisses are DoggyDoDoRaunchy. We need more beasts in the world.
 

Comments

I have seen lipsticks in

Written by Kathy (not verified)

I have seen lipsticks in metal containers...but even they contain some plastic.

I do have a question for you, though...plastic wrapping around products...like the shrunk stuff on so many packages and the standard 'wrapped in plastic just to use up more plastic' around many products...of course, there is no recycle code, but they seem so flimsy. Surely they are recyclable...no?

most plastic that can't be

Written by riotpirate

most plastic that can't be put in the blue box can be taken to the alternative recycling pickup. check www.pacificmobiledepots.com to find out when they'll be in your neighbourhood, and for a list of everything they accept. you can recyle plastic shrink wrap packaging, hard plastic, heck even toothpaste tubes! happy recycling!

Crikey! I better start

Written by Crunchy Chicken (not verified)

Crikey! I better start wearing lipstick.

And what's the deal with shampoo/conditioner bottles (like from Aveda) who have the little recycle swirly logo, but no number to see if you can actually recycle it? Same thing with moisturizer bottles from Estee Lauder and the like.

What can we do with those? Anyone know?

"When the number is omitted,

Written by Kathy (not verified)

"When the number is omitted, the symbol is known as the universal Recycling Symbol, indicating generic recyclable materials. In this case, other text and labels are used to indicate the material(s) used." wikipedia

I''m not sure how helpful this is...it still doesn't tell me if i can put it in my recycle box by the curb...

tlc's picture

A lot of people are confused

Written by tlc

A lot of people are confused by the strange plastic recycling codes, especially since each municipality seems to accept different numbers.

 I used to work in the recycling industry, and my personal suggestion is to throw any hard plastic items into your blue box. (By hard plastic, I mean anything you can't squish into a ball with your hand).  Generally, you cannot recycle household quantities of styrofoam or soft plastic (bags, wrap, etc).  Soft plastic typically has to be swashed into bales to make it recyclable, so you could try going to London Drugs or somewhere that may go through a lot of shrink-wrap in their shipping and receiving dept and maybe they'll add your bags into theirs.  At the recycling sorting depot, all the other hard plastic gets put into 'mixed plastic' bins, baled, and then shipped from the recycling depot to the place where they melt it down... so throw it all in there!

Thanks for providing

Written by EnviroWoman

Thanks for providing clarification TLC.

I've always thought soft plastics couldn't be added to our blue recycling boxes...only hard plastics marked 1, 2, 4, 5, and 7. No others. And, if the plastic isn't marked, it shouldn't be included in our blue box program...but put in the garbage.

I've been meaning to phone the Recycling Council of BC for the 'right' answer to the questions asked above...but haven't had a chance during the work day. Am also reading Garbage Land, hoping that will give me the answer...but it hasn't yet.

TLC, do recycling facilities every offer public tours? I think that would be an eye-opening adventure.

EnviroWoman

Plastic free. Cruelty free. Vegetarian. Chocoholic

tlc's picture

Right - so you'll want to

Written by tlc

Right - so you'll want to keep the bags out of the blue box (they actually can create a big problem at the sorting plants because they plug up the machines), and put in all the other firmer stuff (even if no number on it).

My guess is that the Recycling Council of BC will tell you to follow the information provided by your city, but honestly most cities have different allowable plastics yet they all end up at the same two or three recycling/sorting facilities. Figure that one out.  So if some cities say 1-7, then chances are really good that the recycling facilities will take all the different plastics.

 Public tours... Not sure. You could ask by calling around. It's pretty stinky, I'll warn you of that.

Only one problem with Cargo

Written by Kira (not verified)

Only one problem with Cargo lipsticks ... their first ingredient is "Ricinus communis", Castor bean oil. I have an allergy to "R. communis" ... apparently a common problem, especially for people working directly with the oil.

Stay away if you have allergies, or know you are allergic to Castor Bean oil.

Thanks for the info. I

Written by baby changing tables (not verified)

Thanks for the info. I really had a blast

Add comment

This information will be kept private, and other members of the site will not be able to see it.